Thursday, June 28, 2012

Lone Ranger and Tonto Fist Fight In Heaven Liminality of Thomas and Victor

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMhq1L0cJf0

Despite the forms of new criticism, I find it necessary to step outside of those boundaries for this blog, especially with Sherman Alexie and native American writers in general. By the very nature of the source of native American writing, I have to be able to understand the world outside of the text. I have to be able to understand what is the meaning of the word Indian. My own heritage is mingled with the blood of my Cherokee ancestors on my mother's side. My own son and daughter are doubly blessed with this bloodline. I never saw this heritage as something to be ashamed of or even as something mystical that granted me great mystical powers that would allow me to see better in the dark or catch a deer with my teeth. The fact of the matter is, I never  thought of it at all.  I don't think any white, mixed red and white (pink) person, can really understand what it is like to be an Indian unless they live the life on the reservation.
Alexie's novel masterfully guides us into this world of life on the res.  His rich, vibrant characters come to life and lend us a small lens into the liminal culture that is life on the reservation. The novel centers on two main characters Thomas Builds-the-Fire and Victor Joseph. Victor is the typical reckless reservation Indian, resentful of everthing whether it's Indian or white. His whole goal is to leave the res and get away. Thomas is somewhat of a modern mystic in his own right. He is a weird misunderstood boy who gets through life by telling fantastic stories and retellings of past histories of the people. His only "friend" is Victor.
While the novel depicts Thomas and Victor as two people. It can be argued that they are in fact, two aspects of a trinary being. Thomas represents all that is wise and cultural in the Indian being. He speaks his mind, and lends himself as the anchor of the mind of the being. Victor is the embodiment of all that is strong and savage of the Indian being. His blatant rebellions and actions are steeped in the blood of his people even as he tends to reject that blood. The third aspect of the Indian being is of course, the narrator. Who, like a spirit, moves in the liminal space between the two binaries that are Thomas and Victor. This narrator is the glue and through him we are allowed a window into each aspect of the total being. At times this narrator excises Thomas from Victor and Victor from Thomas and allows an up close view of the psyche inherent in each polar opposite. It is here where we find the true humanity of the being and why that being should never be separated into these poles. Victor is the strength and power and drive of the being, but he lacks the direction and vision that Thomas can give him. Thomas has heart and wisdom that the being needs but is in a weak physical shell incapable of defending or forwarding those ideas.
This novel represenst one of the most compelling ideals of liminality one is likely to find in literature. It has been made into a fine piece of cinema entitled, Smoke Signals.
 Smoke Signals Poster   http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120321/

 Sadly, it does so because the author does not just write about the concepts but is himself one of these liminal beings. As masterful a work as any reader will find and yet, only one of many that adress this liminality of Indian and White. I would also suggest reading at least one other work entitled The Business of Fancy Dancing. Also by Alexie and also in film form.


The Business of Fancydancing Posterhttp://www.imdb.com/title/tt0303313/

With this film I recommend the book first and foremost. The poetry is alive when read aloud.

Saturday, June 23, 2012

Death Incarnation in White Noise


A little background music
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AUO_5EALZoM

In part one of White Noise, Don Delillo makes several statements about reality. He states that the truest aspect of reality is the inevitability of death. But while death is universal, its significance varies widely. For some people, death is a natural cessation of existence; we live, then we die. For others, death is merely a moment of transition in an eternal existence. In White Noise, Delillo creates the idea that death is a tangible idea that we create by speaking it into existence.


The protagonist, Jack Gladney, is a professor at a small liberal arts college. His unique focus on Hitler studies is highly successful. Jack's field of study is based on the true history of Hitler and his regime built on worldwide death and destruction. According to Jack, “Hitler gave me something to grow into and develop toward” (17). For this reason, Jack views death as no more than a work-related statistic. Nazism, genocide, and war are mere rhetoric to teach, and death has little or no meaning except to further a topic. Even at home death seems theoretical. He and his wife sometimes talk about who should die first, but the conversations are lighthearted and trifling.


This attitude slowly changes with the introduction of Jack's associate, Murray, a teacher of pop-culture and its icons, particularly Elvis. Murray is new to the area and Jack decides to take him to some local sites. It is during their visit to “the most photographed barn in America” that Murray's discussion of his belief about death begins to affect Jack's own viewpoint. In Murray's mind, things do not exist until we make them so, but ironically, he also believes that once we name things, they are altered in some way. For example, Murray asserts the barn exists by its visitors' making and imagining. He states that “once you've seen the signs about the barn, it becomes impossible to see the barn” (12), or in other words, the directional signs tell you what to see instead of allowing you to decide for yourself. It became the greatest barn in America not because it really is but because someone has named it so. And its visitors bolster this fabrication by continuing to visit the barn.


What did it look like, how was it different from other barns, how was it similar to other barns? We can't answer these questions because we've read the signs, seen the people snapping the pictures. We can't get outside the aura. We're part of the aura. We're here, we're now. (13)


He and Jack are now part of someone else's idea, which is part of a previous person's idea. Jack himself agrees: “I am the false character that follows the name around” (17).


When Jack begins questioning what is real, he senses an ominous idea hovering at the edges of his existence that remains unseen, dark, and foreboding. He gets a hook into it while lecturing to his students about the plot to kill Hitler. He unknowingly brings the idea to life when he contemplates the idea of plotting:


All plots tend to move deathward. This is the nature of plots. Political plots, terrorist plots, lovers' plots, narrative plots, plots that are part of children's games. We edge nearer to death every time we plot. (26)


Jack wonders why he has said this statement, but by naming death in the plot and in general, he has played his cards and death is now a reality he cannot ignore.


Jack begins to wonder at his previous ignorance of death. Murray fuels his interest further by asserting that in cities people are more distant from death than elsewhere, even though it occurs more often around them. The difference is in a big city you don't take the time to get to know anyone. Death has no meaning because the people are unknown and unnamed. In a small town like Blacksmith you know the type of car someone drives or their dog's name. This makes that person part of your reality, so their death is part of your own reality. In this sense, Jack begins to see the change from death as an impersonal force to Death personified.


Like a constant ringing in the ear, Jack begins to be aware of Death's persistence and the mass ignorance of its power. While watching television he notices his whole family glued to the images of earthquakes and volcanic imagery. He questions his colleagues, “Why is it...that decent, well-meaning and responsible people find themselves intrigued by catastrophe when they see it on television” (65)? His colleague responds with, “Because we are suffering from brain fade. We need an occasional catastrophe to break up the incessant bombardment of information” (66). Murray explains further by saying, “This is because they have forgotten how to look and listen as children. ...we have reversed the relative significance of these things” (67). Because people have been force-fed the unimportant as important, their minds are out of shape from misuse and abuse. We no longer fear Death in the traditional sense as much as we are fascinated by its effect on others.


Jack has become very aware of Death's manifestation and proximity. As he teaches about the Hitler rallies that seemed to worship the regime's death and destruction, he has the revelation that they were something even bigger. Jack realizes that Death is loose in the world and will come, unhindered and with fury to all. Yet Jack sees these fervent, almost rabid, spittle-flying crowds may have served another purpose: protection. Basic survival instinct includes the idea there is safety in numbers. “Crowds came to form a shield against their own dying. To become a crowd is to keep out death. To break off from the crowd is to risk death as an individual” (73). The simple fact is no one wants to face Death alone, and the Nazi crowd was a buffer to its savagery. They allowed the individual to become the mass, and that mass allows an anesthetic against the atrocities and brutalities of Death.

Thursday, June 21, 2012

I'll have the Bailey's Liminal Transition, please.


    

 After completing Bailey's Cafe I realized that this is one of the most pivotal and crucial texts on liminality ever written. Each and every character, with the exception of Bailey himself, lives on the edge or margin of existence. Bailey's itself does not exist fully in this world, “the place sits right on the margin between the edge of the world and infinite possibility, the back door opens out to a void,” (76). The cafe is a superb vehicle to transport the reader into the lives and transitional state of each character. But Bailey himself warns us not to take things at face value, “Every one-liner's got a life under neath it. Every point's got a counter point...Anything really worth hearing in this greasy spoon happens under the surface. You need to know that if you plan to stick around here ...(34, 35).
      The word liminal in itself means transition or in the state of transition. It's very acute definition implies that the subject is in a motion forward or backward into something else. The cafe provides a place where this liminal character can rest and relax on that journey, safe and secure. While not intended as a permanent residence, the regulars have deemed to make it, at least, a long term stopover, and that's okay. While each character is broken in some way, the cafe provides healing. Charles Wilson describes what the characters are feeling as, “They have achieved a peaceful limbo, and because of their apparent resilience and adjustability, they will more likely grow and develop in ways far beyond those who are settled in a comfortable, pigeonholed existence,” (Wilson 128). It is through this peaceful limbo, that the characters themselves come to terms with their own plights. Instead of knocking down or exploiting others, the characters instead develop respect for other and offer a sympathetic, “I know” to others. While all are not healed completely, it is in a forward motion towards the good, and thus presents a positive liminal transition.
Works Cited
Naylor, Gloria. Baile'ys Cafe. Orlando: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1992. Print.
Wilson, Charles E. Gloria Naylor. Westport: Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc., 2001.

I hate jazz. No not really. Well maybe some.



Dave Brubek's Take Five



     I don't hate jazz, I just don't prefer to listen to it. I fully recognize its amazing impact on the world and its contributions to the art and music world, however. This, to me, mishmash of music stylings, if far beyond my uncultured musical ear to capture and appreciate fully. I'm content with that. I am also content with jazz's affects on the rest of the art world, mainly literature. Perhaps no other form of music fully embraces the postmodern idea like jazz music. My knowledge of jazz music is limited only to the monster, Armstrong, Gillespie, Monk, Davis, and mostly “white jazz” like Brubek, yet, all of them masterfully pull together a seeming randomness and stream of consciousness and tie it together beautifully at the center.
      Bailey's Cafe is made of jazz. Gloria Naylor takes seemingly random characters and story lines and weaves them together into a cohesive and well told novel. Like a jazz set, we find a frontman, Bailey, who is the lead and who directs us and generally carries the main tune. The novel is made up of several stories however, and as in jazz, each character gets to showcase their talent, whether it is a prostitute, a mother and wife who has lost it all, or a cross dressing business genius, all have their story to tell. Bailey is the director but also the father figure in the novel. He demands that the reader accord all respect for these women and to treat them with dignity. After each story is told, however, the reader finds themselves doing just that, nodding with respect.

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Liminal Warrior


     I realized that I should have named my blog "Liminal Commuter." My recent return to the world of academia has opened my eyes to the presence of liminal characters in both modern and postmodern literature. Having just spent a semester hip deep in the Delta mud of Faulkner's Yoknapatawpha County, a land rich in liminality, my literature mind is sensitized and trained to seek out these liminals in other works. Now you may very well inquire, "What the devil is a liminal character, my good man?" I'm so glad you might have asked.
     A liminal character by definition is one who lives between two worlds. W.E.B. DuBois called this a double identity or a "twoness." These liminals are most often of mixed genetic heritage, such as half black and white, for example the mulatto children of Thomas Supten in Faulkner's Absalom! Absalom!. These liminals may also be unaware of their heritage as in Twain's Puddin' Head Wilson. More often, these characters are aware of their mixed heritage and must confront it, usually to a very detrimental and tragic ending.
     Kingston's Woman Warrior is a different kind of liminal character, specifically of ethnicity and culture but also of gender and the temporal. The unnamed narrator exists in a world not of DuBois' two realms but of many: feminine, masculine, American, Chinese, past and present. All these worlds exist for her on the same stage and she moves from past to present, real and fantasy with little effort and occasionally with little warning. Kingston does not want her reader to wander off too far and masterfully tethers us to the main character anchored at the center of the stage. She allows just enough slack in the rope to let the reader explore and peek through the curtains into the other worlds that have shaped the central character.
     The first story, No Name Woman, introduces the parameters of Kingston's stage, is the guide for the rest of the novel, and a fantastic example of a postmodern tale. The narrator relates a story which her mother narrates about something she witnessed long ago. The protagonist of the mother's tale is known only as the sister. The sister becomes pregnant out of wedlock and rather than shame the father she decides that it is better to drown herself and the baby. Chinese tradition holds that women who drown can not go into the afterlife and must forever wander the in-between unless they find someone to drown and take their place. The book's narrator, whom we'll call Kingston, finds a connection with the aunt and even fantasizes about the aunt's forbidden passions. Kingston also notes the baby was probably a girl, the aunt most likely still a young girl herself, so in Chinese culture both were basically useless beings. This theme of females being useless sets the tone for the rest of the novel. Kingston relates the stories not as meek little foot-bound girl, but as a woman who strives to be the dragon, the warrior, Fa Mu Lan.
     On casual reading, the novel itself appears to be mainly feminist rhetoric. While feminism is a central theme, the novel has many, many layers. Like the palimpsest of ancient times, Kingston's narrative is a parchment of many ancient events and stories that have been written over and over. Unlike the actual palimpsest, however, the original writings still exist. Kingston herself alludes to this in White Tigers where the character of Fa Mu Lan has the family sins burned into her skin (34-35). Like Fa Mu Lan, Kingston also proudly bears her heritage in her skin and in her writing.
Ideogram for war.

Tuesday, June 12, 2012


I just read the first half of Maxine Hong Kingston's The Woman Warrior. Wow. I had forgotten that I had read the first story and had in fact mentioned the story last semester in my LSIC class with Dr Boyle. I compared some parallels with Murakami's work to the ideals in "No Name Woman." The spirit aspects are very prevalent in both books. I think Murakami is more eloquent, but Kingston cuts in on more deeper levels especially since there are no translation issues to deal with.

After our discussion in class, I wanted to try and read this novel from only one of the aspects of general story triangle. For those of you not in my class, here's how it is set up.


You may have to bigify the image to actually see it. This new fangled technology dumbfounds me. The point of the triangle that I usually read a text from is of course from the reader. I like to enjoy the story and not have to dissect it or probe it or analyze the thing dry. I realize that as a Lit major, that will be the rest of my life and I have to get over it. Rather than go immediately up to the pinnacle however, I shifted over to the other side, the dark side of the moon as Roger Waters would say. This text by its very nature begs you to read it that way Kingston’s story are are not so much a meta narrative as they are meta biographical, or meta cultural. I admit that I was confused at first by Dr Hobby's assignment of this book as a work of postmodernism. The stories I had read were about ancient ghosts and strange, not really old people. After sitting in class and being allowed to see, piece by piece the parts of what makes a work postmodern, I finally see that this work captures nearly every definition. While both Habermas and Focault will disagree about which points make it a postmodern work, they both would have to agree that it fits most of both viewpoints. Kingston does this by expertly blending all that is the definition of what is postmodern into a fine tasting soup of literary cuisine. I love the grafting of Chinese mythology and mystical stories and how they provide a focusing lens on her own life and modern issues. Most notably is her use of the Fa Mu Lan tales and the woman warrior she was. I look forward to finishing this book and further expanding on these ideals, once I see how she ties them all up. A superb piece of fiction and quasi-fiction, she is a true credit to the postmodern set.


Monday, June 11, 2012

The Rules of The Game. A Commentary on The Hunger Games



The rules in the Hunger Games is simple. If you survive, you win, and you can survive however you want to.  The only thing you can't do is hide, the monitors of the game insure that. I began to think about rules after reading this book and especially how rules apply to the postmodern story.  Before, in the pre-modern and the modern forms of literature, there were usually a set form of rules to how a story was written and how a story played out. However, according to Lyotard, there is a theory of the Les grand recit, or a master narrative. All things are just petit histoire or tiny histories that are inter-woven into a grand narrative. The irony of the grand narrative is that for the most part, no one believes in it.
   This concept is prevalent in Hunger Games. We are of course privy to this grand narrative as we are the reader. The story is given in first person, but we are as the reader are part of the meta-narrative and as such we can see the whole set of "rules" even if Katniss does not.  The book is set in the future, but the reader is not in that future yet. What we are however, is a tether pole, a central post where a ball is sent out into that future, still tied to current common ideals and themes. The ball brings back glimpses of those common themes as they are distorted and warped in that future epoch. In the case of the Hunger Games, Collins shows us not only what a government can become but how media and the government and pop culture, can become so inter mingled and meshed that there is little difference in where the lines are drawn. Instead of a nice little compartmentalized TV dinner tray, we now have a pot pie.  The protagonist, Katniss Everdeen, comes from a district of poverty and despair. While the world around her, even in her little dump of a district, is guided by this mish-mash of society, Katniss has managed to keep her priorities segregated. She hunts for food, she takes care of her family, she likes Gale, life goes on. The games change all of that in that they force her to hunt to kill others, she must kill others to save her self and feed her district and family, she hunts to kill others to feed others and Gale the boy she thinks she is in love with but now must "love" another, Peeta. She is now part of that pot pie and she can never just go back to her simple little TV dinner world of district 12.  We as the reader see this coming from way off. We know she's going to win, there are two other books on the shelf, and movie rights to consider. We too are part of the pie.